Geomorphological evolution and ecological response of the River Ehen to the reconnection of a headwater tributary
Evolution géomorphologique et réponse écologique de la rivière Ehen à la reconnexion d'un affluent
Abstract
Freshwater ecosystems are amongst the most threatened in the world. They have been -and
still are- altered by a wide range of human activities; from damming, dredging, mining and
diversion, to water abstraction, pollution and over-exploitation of sediment and biota. Later
recognition of the important ecosystem services provided by rivers, wetlands and floodplains,
triggered a need for the restoration and rehabilitation of degraded freshwater systems. The
protection and conservation of endangered species has been a particular focus of efforts.
The River Ehen, in Northwest England, is one such restoration initiative. The river is naturally
regulated by a post-glacial lake, but its exploitation for water abstraction led to the construction
of a weir and the diversion of a headwater tributary (several decades ago) that previously
discharged just downstream from the lake outlet. Ben Gill is a first order ephemeral tributary
whose diversion halted the natural transfer of water and sediments into the main-stem Ehen.
This had an impact on the natural behaviour of the system and conditions in the river
deteriorated. In the early 2010s, concerns were voiced about the consequences of habitat
deterioration for the survival of the freshwater pearl mussel (Margaritifera margaritifera L.).
This endangered species is present in high densities in the upper Ehen; in fact, the Ehen hosts
the largest remaining population of England. In response to these concerns, the Environment
Agency decided to review the water abstraction licence and restore natural sediment dynamics
in the river by reconnecting the ‘lost’ tributary, Ben Gill.
The objective of the restoration is rather simple in its aim, but complex in its application: restore
physical habitat to sustain the pearl mussel population. This thesis focuses on evaluating the
changes to fluvial processes and resulting physical habitat in response to the restoration actions
and assessing whether these were in line with what we know is suitable for pearl mussels. It
sits on the back of preliminary efforts to characterise the pre-restoration conditions of the River
Ehen.
The reconnection of Ben Gill is the centre-piece of this restoration, so it was crucial to monitor
its evolution in order to assess the volumes and frequency of sediment delivery into the Ehen.
Because the stream is ephemeral, it was possible to capture its topography under dry
conditions, using Structure-from-Motion (SfM) photogrammetry. This technique is becoming
common-place in fluvial geomorphology, but this thesis presents the first example of its
application within a river restoration context. Aerial images were collected from a small UAV
and used to generate 3D models of the channel topography. Successive topographic models
were then compared to determine the volumes of erosion and deposition within the channel
and infer a minimum volume of export to the Ehen. Additionally, given the relatively small size
of the channel (300 m long) and the possibility to install a dense network of ground control
points (necessary to properly geo-reference SfM photogrammetry outputs), it was possible to
test and determine the potential of using a camera with a fish-eye lens, often criticised as
unsuitable for SfM photogrammetry. The results showed that SfM photogrammetry can be
applied using a fish-eye camera, given appropriate calibration, assessment of errors and
bespoke ground control point network. Model accuracy was consistent over time and the
quality high enough to accurately capture the geomorphic evolution of the channel. Confidence
in the results was improved by the unexpectedly large scale of the changes observed. These
changes meant that large volumes of sediment were exported from Ben Gill and deposited in
the Ehen from the early days of the opening of the channel.
As part of monitoring related to the reconnection, the Environment Agency installed a series of
turbidity meters in the Ehen which, after empirical field-based calibration, provided time-series
of suspended sediment concentrations. It was thus possible to assess the changes in the
dynamics of suspended sediments in relation to the reactivation of its headwater subcatchment.
By comparing 2 years prior to and 2 years following the reconnection, it was
possible to characterise the role played by this small, ephemeral but highly dynamic tributary
in driving suspended sediment dynamics in the regulated Ehen. On average, the suspended
sediment load increased by 65% following the reconnection (i.e. for an increase in catchment
size of 1.2%), with most transport occurring through short but intense flow events. This was of
particular interest from a geomorphic process perspective, since most studies of ephemeral
streams are concentrated in arid or Mediterranean regions; little is known about their relative
influence in temperate climate regions. A significant finding from a management perspective is
that the increased suspended sediment loads in the Ehen –if left unchecked– may threaten
mussels and counter other positive changes resulting from the reconnection.
Although mussels can cope with short-lived high suspended sediment events, they are highly
vulnerable to the deposition and accumulation of fines on the riverbed. This is particularly true
for the juveniles that live buried in the top layer sediment for the first few years of their life.
Thus, in-channel fine sediment storage was monitored for over 2 years in the Ehen to assess
the effects that the increased suspended sediment loads had on mussel habitat. Analysis of the
timing of flows in the Ehen compared to those in Ben Gill revealed that in-channel storage was
controlled by the degree of synchronicity between the two streams. High deposition occurred
when Ben Gill was connected but flows did not spill over the weir, while the removal of fines
was only observed for very high discharges in the Ehen. As with suspended sediment loads, the
storage of fines in the riverbed increased following the reconnection.
The geomorphic adjustments in the Ehen in response to the newly restored delivery of coarse
sediment from Ben Gill was assessed by looking at changes in grain size distribution, surface
particle mobility and cross-sectional topography. A large fraction of the material exported from
Ben Gill accumulated at the confluence, forming downstream a continuously growing
depositional bar. Using the same SfM photogrammetry technique used for Ben Gill, the growth
and role of the depositional bar as a transient storage were assessed. It appears, at least in the
first two years following the reconnection, only a relatively small fraction of material deposited
on the bar is actually re-mobilised and conveyed downstream in the Ehen; most deposits
remain on the bar which consequently has kept growing in size. Nevertheless, topographic
surveys have confirmed visual observations of deposition in the first 300 m downstream from
the confluence, notably a new lateral bar on the true right bank. Other areas have been subject
to erosion. Grain size distribution has also changed in the most active morphological units, with
an overall trend towards a fining of the bed texture. Surface particle mobility has increased
since the reconnection, but still remains rather limited despite the occurrence of very high
flows during the period of this study. Nevertheless, this increase in mobility is significant in the
two most active morphological units and, along with the observed changes in topography, bode
well for a continued improvement of conditions in the future.
The hydraulic and geomorphic changes observed in the Ehen as a result of flow regulation and
the diversion of Ben Gill are thought to have facilitated excessive growth of algae on the river
bed. To investigate this, a 13-month study of the factors potentially influencing algal growth,
including the abundance of grazing invertebrates, was undertaken. Monthly surveys were
undertaken at two sites in the Ehen and two in Croasdale Beck, an unregulated tributary of the
Ehen. This work emphasised the different temporal dynamics of algal growth in the Ehen
compared to Croasdale. Algal abundance, represented using total chlorophyll-a, varied
according to the magnitude of bed disturbance in the period preceding sampling dates.
Invertebrate communities differed between the Ehen and Croasdale, largely reflecting changes
in the abundance of different functional feeding groups. Generalised Estimating Equations suggested some of the variation in total algal abundance (chlorophyll-al) could be accounted
for by grazer abundance. However, ordination-based analysis of the composition of the algal
community suggested more complex interactions, with environmental controls (flow
hydraulics, nutrients, bed stability) more important than simply grazing pressure.
The reconnection of Ben Gill to its main-stem Ehen is a unique example of non-invasive
catchment-scale restoration initiative of an upland river. In this sense, it differs from some
rehabilitation projects whose actions are limited to things such as artificial gravel
augmentation, the installation of deflectors or other in-channel features, or in some cases the
‘landscape gardening’ of a target reach. The focus of the Ehen project is on restoring fluvial
processes which, in turn, will help achieve the objective of improving physical habitat for the
pearl mussel. Although proper assessment of the response of the pearl mussel population to
the restoration will require more time and investigation, the primary goal of the reconnection
has been achieved; the natural delivery of coarse sediments has been reactivated and material
is being conveyed downstream the upper Ehen, creating new geomorphic features and
increasing habitat diversity. As is the case with any restoration or rehabilitation project, there
has been uncertainty and unpredictability as to how the tributary might behave and how the
river might respond. The primary and most worrying manifestation has been the marked
increase in fine sediment loads. Given the sensitivity of the focal species, these high loads have
been a cause for concern for the government agencies and conservation groups involved in the
project. This has raised interesting questions about the possible need for intervention, though
for the moment the decision has been made to simply monitor how the situation evolves. This
and all other elements of the reconnection have ensured that the restoration of the Ehen has
been an invaluable learning experience from a management perspective, and especially
regarding the role of monitoring to help assess river response and the achievement of target
objectives.
Le sujet de ma thèse portait sur l’évaluation des effets écologiques et géomorphologiques d’un projet de réhabilitation de rivière. Ce projet avait pour but de ‘renaturaliser’ les dynamiques fluviales et améliorer les conditions d’habitat de la population de mulette perlière, en reconnectant un affluent détourné dans les années 1970. L’utilisation de la technologie photogrammétrie ‘Structure-from-Motion’ a permis le suivi de l’évolution géomorphologique de l’affluent, en produisant des ‘DEMs of Difference (DoDs)’. Ceux-ci ont servi à observer les changements sédimentaires et géomorphologiques de l’affluent, et à estimer son budget sédimentaire. Les effets du renouvellement de la dynamique sédimentaire sur l’activité de la rivière principale ont été suivis grâce à la combinaison de traceurs et de modélisation hydraulique. L’intérêt principal était d’étudier le lien entre conditions hydrauliques et mobilité du lit, et dans quelle mesure ce nouvel apport sédimentaire influe sur l’activité morpho-dynamique de la rivière. Les conséquences sur la dynamique des sédiments fins ont aussi été évaluées, en étudiant la dynamique de stockage des particules fines au sein de la matrice sédimentaire, ainsi qu’en déterminant le budget de la charge en suspension de la section d’étude, ces éléments étant complexifiés par la nature éphémère de l’affluent. Enfin, la dernière partie était consacrée à l’analyse des interactions entre l’hydrologie, la stabilité du lit, le développement des algues et les communautés d’invertébrés. Une campagne de terrain de douze mois a permis de collecter des données sur les peuplements macro-benthiques, la biomasse algale, ainsi que des mesures de débit et de stabilité de fond. Ces données ont alimenté une série de modèles multivariés, dont le but était d’étudier les interactions entre les algues, les invertébrés brouteurs et les facteurs de perturbations hydrauliques et géomorphologiques.
Fichier principal
Baptiste_Marteau_Thesis_PhD_2017_final_compressed.pdf (4.1 Mo)
Télécharger le fichier
Origin | Files produced by the author(s) |
---|